Islanders Baseball has sent several players on to the professional ranks since the program's inception in 2000. Here are the players currently active with independent and affiliated teams.

Please email Islanders Athletics if you notice any inaccuracies or have any additions.
 

Player	Name	Years with Islanders	Current Team	Drafted
	Trevor Foss	2009-13	Lake County Captains Midwest League Class A Cleveland Indians	2013 - 22nd Round Angels, 667 Overall
	Trevor Belicek	2012-15	Frederick Keys Carolina League Class A Advanced Baltimore Orioles	2015 - 16th Round Braves, 480 Overall
	Jacob Dorris	2012-15	Corpus Christi Hooks Texas League Class AA Houston Astros	2015 - Free Agent, Astros
	Casey Thomas	2015-16	AZL Athletics Arizona League Rookie Oakland A's	2016 - 34th Round Oakland A's
	Chris Falwell	2016	Salem-Keizer Volcanoes Northwest League Class A Short Season San Francisco Giants	2016 - 16th Round San Francisco Giants
	Garrett Harris	2015-16	AZL Royals Arizona League Rookie Kansas City Royals	2016 - Free Agent Kansas City Royals

• Here are the Islanders who spent time in the professional ranks:

2005 – Chuck Carter – St. Louis Cardinals – 27th round, 830th overall
2005 – Trey Hearne – St. Louis Cardinals – 28th round, 860th overall
2005 – Jaime Landin – St. Louis Cardinals – Free Agent
2008 – Omar Gutierrez – San Diego Padres – 29th round, 885th overall
2008 – Chase Williams – San Diego Padres – Free Agent
2011 – Todd Simko – Washington Nationals – 21st round, 637th overall
2011 – Matthew Holland – Philadelphia Phillies – 22nd round, 691st overall
2012 – Daniel Minor – Houston Astros – 9th round, 279th overall
2013 – Eric Weiss – Los Angeles Angels – 35th round, 1057th overall
2013 – Bobby Buckner – Chicago Cubs – Free Agent